Domestic Violence: Are Existing Laws Enough?
WU Professor Robert Kert, an expert in criminal law, analyzes how Austria’s legal protections against domestic violence have evolved
Despite numerous legislative reforms, domestic violence remains a pressing problem in Austria. Although preventive measures and criminal law protections have been steadily expanded over the past 30 years, the number of people affected – particularly women – remains high. WU Professor Robert Kert explains how Austria’s legal framework for protecting people from domestic violence has evolved, whether the measures introduced have been effective, and what further action is needed.
Domestic violence refers to acts of violence between people who live or have lived in the same household or who have a close family or intimate relationship. It includes, in particular, violence between current or former partners and between parents and children. Women are disproportionately affected. According to European surveys, around 38% of women in Austria have experienced physical or psychological violence in an intimate relationship at least once in their lives.
Every year, from November 25 to December 10, the United Nations’ international Orange the World campaign raises awareness of violence against women and draws public attention to the question of how those affected can be protected effectively. In Austria, legal protections against violence have been expanded progressively since the 1990s.
A turning point in the response to domestic violence
Austria’s first Domestic Violence Act (Gewaltschutzgesetz) came into force 30 years ago. Among other measures, it introduced eviction and barring orders, allowing the police to remove individuals who pose a threat from a shared home and prohibit them from reentering it. These measures under police law were later supplemented by restraining orders, mandatory violence prevention counseling, and multi-agency case conferences.
According to Robert Kert, professor of criminal law and criminal procedure at WU, this legislation marked a paradigm shift. “With the first Domestic Violence Act, lawmakers recognized domestic violence as a societal problem and reached a major milestone in improving protection from domestic violence,” Kert says. Unlike many subsequent reforms, the first Domestic Violence Act did not focus on creating new criminal offenses or increasing penalties. Instead, it introduced preventive protections under police law.
Expanding protection under criminal law
Criminal law has been reformed several times as part of efforts to further strengthen protection against violence. In 2009, the second Domestic Violence Act expanded protections for women and children by introducing the criminal offense of “continued use of violence.” This provision has enabled the criminal justice system to address and punish prolonged patterns of abuse more effectively.
To implement the Istanbul Convention, the 2015 Criminal Law Amendment Act (Strafrechtsänderungsgesetz) expanded existing provisions and introduced new criminal offenses. These included “forced marriage” and “violation of sexual autonomy.” The reform also required courts to give greater weight in sentencing to violence against family members and violence committed in the presence of children.
The third Domestic Violence Act of 2019 introduced further changes to criminal law. These included higher minimum sentences for certain violent offenses, stricter rules for repeat offenders, and increased maximum sentences for severe forms of continued violence. Penalties for rape were also increased.
Are harsher penalties more effective?
Although many of these reforms introduced stricter criminal penalties, Kert sees no clear evidence that these changes have had a positive effect. Despite the legislative changes, the number of women affected by violence remains high. “Harsher penalties alone are not enough to prevent violence effectively,” Kert says. “People who commit acts of violence generally do not base their actions on a rational assessment of the potential sentence.”
In some circumstances, harsher sentences may even be counterproductive. Ahead of the 2019 reform, victim support organizations warned that severe penalties might discourage those affected from reporting violence, particularly when the perpetrator is a family member.
Greater emphasis on prevention and awareness
In Kert’s view, the future of protection against violence lies not in ever-harsher penalties but primarily in prevention, awareness, and effective support for those affected. Many people are still reluctant to report violence. Their reasons range from fear of an abusive family member and a lack of confidence in the available safeguards to concerns that reporting the abuse could cause the situation to escalate further.
It is essential to inform people affected by domestic violence about their rights and the protections available to them. Public authorities must also be as accessible as possible. At the same time, the police, the courts, and other responsible institutions need to provide an environment that is responsive to the needs of victims.
Kert also sees room for improvement in the enforcement of existing protective measures. Barring and restraining orders are important tools for breaking cycles of violence. Their effectiveness, however, depends largely on consistent monitoring and enforcement. Kert also advocates expanding forensic examination centers for people affected by violence. These centers can document injuries professionally and make it easier to preserve evidence for subsequent legal proceedings.
Kert takes a nuanced view of the Austrian federal government’s plans for the electronic monitoring of high-risk perpetrators, as set out in its 2025–2029 government program. While electronic monitoring could make it easier to supervise these individuals, it would also constitute a significant interference with fundamental rights and would therefore have to be designed with particular legal care.
Any such measure, Kert argues, should require a court order and a reliable risk assessment to determine when electronic monitoring is genuinely necessary and proportionate.
Further Information
Kert, R. (2026): Criminal Law Protection Against Domestic Violence. In: Interdisciplinary Journal of Family Law (iFamZ), 21(2), 132–136. Available at: https://linda.lindeverlag.at/Dokument/627951/
Federal Ministry for Women, Science, and Research: Domestic Violence/Violence in the Private Sphere
EU Gender-Based Violence Survey: EU Gender-Based Violence Survey | European Institute for Gender Equality
Federal Act of January 23, 1974, on Offenses Punishable by Law (StGB)
Security Police Act (in particular §§ 38–38b)